Both Open Bidding and header bidding exist for the same reason: to let more buyers compete for each impression at the same time. They do it in different places, with different trade-offs. Here's how they compare.
The short version
- Header bidding (usually Prebid.js) runs the extra auction in the visitor's browser, before the ad server is called.
- Open Bidding is Google's server-side version. Ad Manager calls the participating exchanges from Google's servers, during its own auction.
In both cases, the winning bids compete with Google Ad Exchange and your other demand. The difference is where the calls happen and who manages them.
Side by side
| Header bidding (Prebid) | Open Bidding | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | In the browser | On Google's servers |
| Page weight | Adds JavaScript and requests | Little extra on the page |
| Setup | Adapters, line items or equivalent, ongoing upkeep | Configured inside Ad Manager |
| Choice of partners | Any partner with a Prebid adapter | Partners that participate in Open Bidding |
| Fees | Set by each partner | Google charges a fee on Open Bidding transactions, on top of partner fees |
| Reporting | Split across Prebid analytics and partner reports | Inside Ad Manager reporting |
Where header bidding is stronger
Header bidding gives you the widest choice of buyers. Almost every SSP has a Prebid adapter, so you're not limited to the exchanges that work with Google's programme.
It's also more transparent. Prebid is open source, you control the configuration, and you can see bid-level data through analytics adapters. Some buyers also bid more readily in the browser, where they can read their own identifiers directly.
The cost is weight and effort. Each bidder adds work for the page, and someone has to maintain the setup.
Where Open Bidding is stronger
Open Bidding is lighter on the page because the calls happen server-side. It's set up inside Ad Manager, so there's less code to maintain and the reporting sits in the same place as the rest of your data.
The limits are choice and control. You can only use exchanges that take part, the auction logic is Google's, and Google takes a fee on those transactions. Server-side calls can also see less about the user than browser calls, which can lower some bids.
Why most setups use both
These aren't really competitors. In practice, publishers often:
- Run a small, focused Prebid setup with the partners that bid best in the browser.
- Turn on Open Bidding for exchanges that perform well server-side.
- Let both compete with Ad Exchange inside Ad Manager's auction.
The thing to avoid is calling the same partner through both routes without a reason. That can mean the partner bids against itself, adds load and muddies the reports. Decide which route each partner uses and review it from time to time.
How to decide
Look at the numbers, not the theory:
- Check each partner's win rate and average price, per route.
- Compare what each adds in revenue against what it costs in page speed.
- Keep partners that win often enough to justify their weight.
- Make sure every active partner is listed correctly in your ads.txt.
If you're unsure where Ad Exchange fits in all this, start with what Google Ad Exchange is.
A quick health check
If you already run both, a few questions show whether the setup is working or just busy:
- Who actually wins? List each partner's share of won impressions over the last month. Partners that almost never win are candidates for removal.
- Is the same partner on both routes? If so, check whether one route clearly outperforms the other, and keep only that one.
- What's the timeout costing? Look at how many Prebid bids arrive after the timeout. A high late-bid count means either the timeout is too tight or the partner is slow.
- Do the reports reconcile? Some difference between Ad Manager and partner reports is normal. A large, growing gap is worth investigating.
- Has page speed changed? Compare Core Web Vitals before and after adding partners, not only revenue.
Run this check every few months. Demand partners change their behaviour, prices move with the seasons, and a setup that was right last year can quietly drift. Small, regular clean-ups beat a big rebuild once revenue has already dropped.
Finally, remember that more partners also means more ads.txt lines to keep accurate and more contracts and payment terms to track. Simplicity has value of its own.
Want both set up and tuned for you? For the sites we manage, Bidora runs Ad Exchange, Open Bidding and Prebid together and reviews partners regularly. Talk to us about joining Bidora MCM.